Quick Answer: Buy a well cap by the casing’s outside diameter, not its nominal size: a “6 in.” cap seals on 6-5/8 in. OD casing, a 4 in. cap on 4-1/2 in., per Boshart’s tech sheet. Choose a sanitary, watertight cap with a compression gasket and a #24-mesh screened vent, certified to ASSE 1093 / WSC PAS-97. For most 4-6 in. casings, the Merrill WCO Series ($86-$128 on merrillmfg.com, November 11, 2026) is the best value; the Boshart WTCC-A is the pick if you want a cap that locks. Skip old set-screw caps without a gasket: EPA Region 8 says not to use them.

A well cap is the cheapest part of a private well and the one that keeps everything else clean. According to the U.S. Geological Survey, more than 43 million Americans get their drinking water from private wells, and on almost every drilled well the only thing between the open casing and insects, mice, runoff and lawn clippings is a few pounds of aluminum, cast iron or plastic. When it cracks, loses its gasket or gets knocked off by a mower, surface contamination has a direct path into the water.

We compared the sanitary well caps that US well owners and contractors actually buy, using the makers’ tech sheets and store listings (Boshart, Merrill Manufacturing, American Granby, Baker/Monitor, Flojak) and wellhead rules from EPA Region 8 and the Minnesota Department of Health. Prices come from merrillmfg.com, rcworst.com, flojak.com and sunnydazedecor.com, all checked on November 11, 2026. We don’t test products ourselves; every dimension, certification and price below comes from the source named next to it, and the height math is our own arithmetic on those published numbers.

Check current prices on eBay →

How to size a well cap: measure the outside diameter

Well caps are named by the casing’s nominal inside diameter (ID), but they seal on the outside diameter (OD). Boshart says so directly on its WTCC tech sheet: its 6 in. cap fits a 6 in. or 6-1/4 in. ID casing and “is designed to seal on the 6-5/8” (OD)”. Wrap a tape measure around the casing and divide by 3.14, or measure straight across the top with a caliper. These are the sizes the makers list:

Nominal casing size (ID)Casing OD the cap seals onExample caps (maker part numbers)
4 in.4-1/2 in.Merrill WCOS400, WCOP404P, WCABS400, WCB400; Boshart WTCC-C04; Flojak 4 in.
4-1/2 in.5 in.Boshart WTCC-C045
5 in.5-9/16 in.Merrill WCOS500, WCOP504P, WCB500; Boshart WTCC-A05 / WTCC-C05
5 in.5-1/2 in.Merrill WCP500
5-5/8 in.6 in.Boshart WTCC-C056
6 in. or 6-1/4 in.6-5/8 in.Merrill WCOS600, WCI6, WCABS600, WC600, WCB600; Boshart WTCC-A06; American Granby WC6; Monitor 6WPSM
6-5/8 in. (also 6.9 in. OD PVC SDR21)7 in.Boshart WTCC-A066-12 / WTCC-C066-12
8 in.8-5/8 in.Merrill WC800, WCB800; Boshart WTCC-C08-12

Sources: Boshart WTCC-A/WTCC-C tech sheet (V6) and variant listings on merrillmfg.com, November 11, 2026.

Five-inch casing is where guessing goes wrong: Boshart and Merrill sell caps for three different outside diameters (5 in., 5-1/2 in. and 5-9/16 in.) that could all be called “five inch”. Also note the conduit tap size (1 in., 1-1/4 in. or 1-1/2 in.) if your pump wire runs through rigid conduit into the cap, and whether you need a ground screw to bond a steel casing; several Merrill caps come in a “G” version for that.

Sanitary cap vs. set-screw cap: what the rules say

There are two kinds of caps on American wells. The older kind slips over the casing and is held by set screws on the side. The sanitary kind has a compression gasket squeezed between the cap and the casing by bolts, plus a screened vent. EPA Region 8’s “Simple Fixes for Wellheads” sheet is blunt about the difference: “Well caps with set screws on the sides of the cap may not have a gasket. If not, do not use them.” It asks owners to replace damaged or leaky caps with “vermin-proof, premium, watertight ones” and says no caulk is acceptable for any well opening.

The state rules point the same way:

A well cap is not the same as a well seal. Wells with an above-ground jet pump often have a seal that fits inside the casing and grips one or two drop pipes; Merrill’s WS and WSP well seals start at $30-$33. If your pump sits on top of the well, our shallow well pump guide explains that setup. A cap is for wells where the water leaves underground through a pitless adapter, which is the case for nearly every submersible pump.

Well caps compared at a glance

CapMaterialCasing sizesVentListed standardPrice (Nov 11, 2026)
Merrill WCO SeriesAluminum top, PVC base4, 5, 6 in.1/2 or 3/4 in. screenedPAS-1, PAS-97 (Merrill)$86-$128 (merrillmfg.com)
Boshart WTCC-A (locking)Aluminum, stainless bolts5, 6, 6-5/8 in. (cast iron WTCC-C: 4-8 in.)Two 3/4 in., 24 meshASSE 1093-2019, PAS-97 (2019)$113.13 list, 5 in. WTCC-A05 (Boshart)
American Granby WC6Cast iron, powder coat6 in. (6-5/8 in. OD)Factory screenedASSE 1093-2019, PAS-97 (2019)$127.10; $150.20 with 1-1/4 in. tap (RC Worst)
Merrill WCOPPUV-resistant molded plastic4, 5 in.1/2 or 5/8 in., stainless screenPAS-2, PAS-97, ASSE 1093$38.50-$53.50 (merrillmfg.com)
Merrill ABS SeriesHigh-impact ABS resin4, 6 in.7/16 in.PAS-2, PAS-97, ASSE 1093$84 (4 in.), $96 (6 in.)
Merrill WCI SeriesPainted cast iron6 in.3/8 in. or 1 in. tappedPAS-2, PAS-97, ASSE 1093-2019$121-$160 (merrillmfg.com)
Monitor 6WPSM PremiumGray cast iron6 in.1-1/4 in. 71PS, 24 mesh stainlessPAS-97 (04); approved IL, MI, WI$306.35 (RC Worst)
Merrill WCB SeriesCast, machined and painted in the USA4, 5, 6, 8, 10 in.1-2 in. ventPAS-1, PAS-2, PAS-97, ASSE 1093$140 (4 in.) to $1,860 (8 in.)
Flojak well cap with gripperCast and machined aluminum4, 5, 6, 8 in.Not statedNone stated$82.80-$99.00 (flojak.com)

1. Merrill WCO Series — Best Overall for 4-6 in. Casings

Merrill Manufacturing WCO Series Sanitary Watertight Well Cap

Aluminum top · PVC base · screened vent · conduit tapping · 4, 5 and 6 in. casing · $86-$128
  • Sold direct on merrillmfg.com on November 11, 2026: 4 in. (4-1/2 in. OD) from $86 (WCOS400), 5 in. (5-9/16 in. OD) from $90 (WCOS500), 6 in. (6-5/8 in. OD) from $99 (WCOS600).
  • Options cost a little more: a ground screw (WCOG600, $112), a 1-1/4 in. top tap for conduit (WCOC600, $117) or both (WCOGC600, $128).
  • Merrill lists PAS-1 and PAS-97 certification, a watertight seal and a built-in screened vent for pressure equalization.
  • The PVC base will not rust on a steel or PVC casing, and the aluminum top takes a custom nameplate if your driller wants one.

The WCO is the cap we would point most homeowners to because it covers the three common casing sizes at under $130 in every configuration, comes with the vent and conduit tapping already in place, and is sold at a published price by the company that makes it. If your casing is 4 or 5 in. and you don’t need an aluminum top, Merrill’s molded-plastic WCOPP (pick 4) does the same sanitary job for about $40.

2. Boshart WTCC-A — Best Locking Well Cap

Boshart WTCC-A Watertight Two-Piece Locking Well Cap (aluminum)

Aluminum · five 18-8 stainless bolts · two 3/4 in. 24-mesh vents · padlock hasp · $113.13 list (5 in.)
  • Certified to ASSE 1093-2019 and WSC PAS-97 (2019), covering tamper resistance, venting and water resistance, per Boshart's tech sheet.
  • The 1 in. wide molded gasket seals even when the casing was not cut square; Boshart says it seals as far as 1-1/2 in. down from the top of the casing.
  • Two brass vents with 24-mesh stainless screen (0.354 sq. in. total open area); Boshart says they exceed PAS-97 requirements.
  • Includes a ground bolt and wire terminals for up to 8-gauge wire, and a set screw that bonds the lower ring to a steel casing. The cap is 3.035 in. tall.

Pick the WTCC-A if the well sits near a road, a property line or anywhere kids play: it is the only cap here designed to take a padlock (not included). Boshart sells through distributors, so its website shows a list price rather than a store price: $113.13 for the 5 in. WTCC-A05 on November 11, 2026, with net pricing on request. The aluminum version comes in 5 in., 6 in. (1 in. or 1-1/4 in. conduit) and 6-5/8 in. sizes; the cast iron WTCC-C adds 4, 4-1/2, 5-5/8 and 8 in. The 6-5/8 in. model also seals on 6.9 in. OD PVC SDR21 casing, which is a size most caps don’t fit.

3. American Granby WC6 — Best Cast Iron Cap for 6 in. Steel Casing

American Granby WC6 Cast Iron Watertight Well Cap

Cast iron · blue powder coat · 1 in. IPS conduit tap · factory-installed screen vents · 6 in. · $127.10
  • Fits 6 in. and 6-1/4 in. ID casing with a 6-5/8 in. OD, the most common steel casing on drilled home wells.
  • American Granby says all its WC Series caps are certified watertight to ASSE 1093-2019 and WSC PAS-97 (2019).
  • Wide rubber gasket; American Granby claims the body is 20% heavier than comparable watertight caps.
  • RC Worst listed it at $127.10 on November 11, 2026, or $150.20 for the WC6-125 with a 1-1/4 in. conduit tap.

Cast iron is heavier and harder to knock loose than plastic, which matters where a mower or snowplow passes close to the well. The WC6 is the lowest-priced cast iron cap with a 2019-edition certification we found, $6.10 more than Merrill’s own cast iron WCI6 ($121) and less than half the price of the Monitor 6WPSM.

4. Merrill WCOPP — Best Budget Sanitary Cap

Merrill Manufacturing WCOPP Series Sanitary Watertight Cap

UV-resistant molded plastic · stainless steel screen · acorn nuts · 3 or 4 bolts · 4 and 5 in. · $38.50-$53.50
  • 4 in. (4-1/2 in. OD): $38.50 with 3 bolts (WCOP403P), $39.50 with 4 bolts (WCOP404P), $53.00 with a ground screw.
  • 5 in. (5-9/16 in. OD): $40.00 (WCOP503P), $42.00 (WCOP504P), $53.50 with a ground screw.
  • Merrill lists it as certified to PAS-2 and PAS-97 and ASSE 1093 listed by the Water Systems Council.
  • Gasket seal, stainless screen behind the vent and acorn nuts that keep the bolt threads from rusting.

This is the cheapest cap we found with a listed sanitary certification, and for a 4 or 5 in. PVC casing it is all most wells need. It isn’t made for 6 in. casing; for that size the lowest-priced certified plastic option is Merrill’s ABS Series at $96.

5. Merrill ABS Series — Best Plastic Cap for 6 in. Casing

Merrill Manufacturing ABS Series Sanitary Well Cap

High-impact ABS resin · vermin-proof · 7/16 in. vent · 4 and 6 in. · $84-$96
  • WCABS400 for 4 in. (4-1/2 in. OD) at $84, WCABS600 for 6 in. (6-5/8 in. OD) at $96 on merrillmfg.com.
  • Certified to PAS-2, PAS-97 and ASSE 1093, per Merrill.
  • Built for pitless adapters and Merrill's MCK and SMCK pitless kits.

At $96 the ABS cap is the cheapest certified way to cap a 6 in. casing, $3 under the aluminum-topped WCOS600. Plastic won’t corrode, but it’s lighter than cast iron, so it’s best where nothing heavy is likely to hit the well.

6. Monitor 6WPSM Premium — Best Premium Cap

Baker/Monitor 6WPSM Premium Watertight Well Cap with Screened Air Vent

Gray cast iron · green baked finish · 1-1/2 in. conduit connection · 1-1/4 in. 71PS vent, 24-mesh stainless · 6 in. · $306.35
  • Fits 6 in. ID, 6-5/8 in. OD casing; secured to the casing with a compression gasket.
  • The top comes off without disturbing the seal, the conduit or the wiring, so a pump service doesn't mean resealing the well.
  • Monitor says it can serve as a vacuum seal when the conduit is plugged, and lists approval in Illinois, Michigan and Wisconsin.
  • Listed as conforming to WSC PAS-97 (04), the 2004 edition of the standard; Boshart and American Granby cite the 2019 edition.

The 6WPSM is the cap for someone who wants the separate top and the larger 1-1/4 in. vent and is willing to pay $306.35 (RC Worst, November 11, 2026) for it, about $180 more than the American Granby. For most homes the extra money buys convenience during pump service rather than a better seal.

7. Merrill WCB Series — Best Heavy-Duty Cap for Large Conduit

Merrill Manufacturing WCB Series Sanitary Watertight Cap

Machined and painted in the USA · 1-1/2 in. conduit tapping · 1-2 in. vent · 4 to 10 in. · $140-$2,230
  • WCB400 (4 in.) $140, WCB500 (5 in.) $230, WCB600 (6 in.) $321, WCB800 (8 in.) $1,860; the 10 in. WCB100 ($2,230) showed as unavailable on November 11, 2026.
  • Listed to PAS-1, PAS-2, PAS-97 and ASSE 1093 by the Water Systems Council.
  • Takes Merrill's galvanized mushroom vents (WV100 $38 to WV200 $75.50) as replacements.

The WCB is overkill for a typical house well. It makes sense when a large pump cable needs 1-1/2 in. conduit or for an 8 in. irrigation or farm well, where Merrill’s simpler WC800 ($367) is the cheaper certified alternative.

What the same 6 in. casing costs to cap

For one 6 in. (6-5/8 in. OD) casing, the price spread on November 11, 2026 was eight-fold, and the cheapest option is not a sanitary cap:

Cap for 6-5/8 in. ODPriceStoreSanitary standard listed
Merrill VC600 aluminum vent cap$39.00merrillmfg.comNone listed
Flojak 6 in. well cap with gripper (hand pump mount)$94.80flojak.comNone stated
Merrill WCABS600 (ABS)$96.00merrillmfg.comPAS-97, ASSE 1093
Merrill WCOS600 (aluminum/PVC)$99.00merrillmfg.comPAS-97
Merrill WCI6 (cast iron)$121.00merrillmfg.comPAS-97, ASSE 1093-2019
American Granby WC6 (cast iron)$127.10rcworst.comPAS-97 (2019), ASSE 1093-2019
Merrill WC600$196.00merrillmfg.comPAS-97, ASSE 1093
Monitor 6WPSM Premium$306.35rcworst.comPAS-97 (04)
Merrill WCB600$321.00merrillmfg.comPAS-97, ASSE 1093

The takeaway: a certified sanitary cap for the most common casing size starts at $96, only $57 more than an uncertified vent cap. Flojak’s caps exist to mount its hand pump; if you are adding one, our best hand pump for well water guide covers the kits, and Flojak’s own description notes that some caps clamp with side bolts while others screw into a threaded ring.

Well covers: what fits over a cap and what doesn’t

“Well cover” means two different things. On a dug or bored well several feet across, the cover is a sealed concrete or steel lid that a contractor builds; it is not something you buy by casing size, and a cracked one is a job for a licensed well contractor. On a drilled well, people use “well cover” for a decorative fake rock or wishing-well box placed over the cap. That is fine if three rules hold: the sanitary cap stays on underneath, the vent can still breathe, and the cover lifts off so the cap can be inspected. Minnesota’s health department, in its wellhead guidance, also recommends marking the well so it can be seen above snow and putting at least three protective posts around it, which a hollow rock does not replace.

Size is where most fake rocks fail. Sunnydaze, one of the few makers that publishes interior sizes, sells its faux landscape rocks for septic risers, irrigation valves and outlets:

Sunnydaze faux rock coverOutside size (W x D x H)What fits inside (Sunnydaze sizing guide)Price (Nov 11, 2026)
11 in. H12.5 x 8.5 x 11 in.Not rated; shorter than any code-height casing$52.95
14 in. H22.75 x 19.5 x 14 in.Not rated; shorter than a 12 in. casing plus cap$82.95
22 in. H18 x 17.25 x 22 in.Objects up to 10 in. tall, under 16 in. wide$94.95
21.5 in. H (4.2 lb)24.5 x 21 x 21.5 in.Objects up to 16 in. tall, under 12 in. wide$129.00

Now add a well. A casing at Minnesota’s 12 in. minimum plus a 3.035 in. Boshart cap stands about 15 in. tall, which fits under the 21.5 in. rock with an inch to spare (a 6 in. WTCC cap is 9.657 in. wide, under the 12 in. limit). At EPA Region 8’s 18 in. outdoor height, the same well is about 21 in. tall and fits under none of them. The 22 in. rock looks tall enough but tapers so sharply that Sunnydaze rates it for objects only 10 in. tall. Measure your casing height plus the cap before you buy a cover, and never shorten a casing or mound soil around it to make a cover fit.

How to replace a well cap

  1. Turn off the pump’s breaker. The pump cable comes up through the cap, and on many wells the splice or conduit connection sits right under it.
  2. Measure the casing OD and note the conduit size and whether there is a ground wire bonded to the old cap.
  3. Remove the old cap and any rope or chain running through it. EPA Region 8 recommends removing pump hoists that pass through the cap because they make a proper seal hard to achieve.
  4. Check the casing top for cracks or rust-through. If the casing itself is damaged, stop: that is a different repair, covered in our well casing repair guide.
  5. Fit the new cap, reconnect the ground wire to the cap’s ground bolt or screw, and tighten the bolts evenly so the gasket compresses all the way around.
  6. Point the vent down and make sure its screen is intact.
  7. Test the water. Anything that was open to the air may have let bacteria in. Use our well water testing guide, and if coliform shows up, the shock chlorination steps in our iron bacteria well water guide apply.

Some states treat work on a well as repair work that requires a licensed contractor; Minnesota’s guidance for noncommunity water systems says all alteration and repair work must be done by an MDH-licensed well contractor. Check with your state well program before you start.

Recalls. The Consumer Product Safety Commission’s recall database returned no recall with “well cap” in the title or product name on November 11, 2026.

The bottom line

Measure the outside diameter of the casing first, then buy a sanitary cap with a gasket and a screened vent that lists ASSE 1093 / WSC PAS-97. For a 4, 5 or 6 in. casing, the Merrill WCO Series ($86-$128) is the best value and the Merrill WCOPP ($38.50-$53.50) the cheapest certified option on 4-5 in. casing. Choose the Boshart WTCC-A ($113.13 list for 5 in.) if you want a cap that locks, or the American Granby WC6 ($127.10) for a heavy cast iron cap on 6 in. steel. Replace any set-screw cap without a gasket, and make sure a decorative cover is tall enough to sit over a code-height casing instead of the other way around. For the pump below the cap, see our best submersible well pump picks.

Prices were checked on merrillmfg.com, boshart.com (list price), rcworst.com, flojak.com and sunnydazedecor.com on November 11, 2026, and change often. Specs and certifications come from the makers’ tech sheets and listings; code requirements from EPA Region 8 and the Minnesota Department of Health. We don’t test products ourselves.