Quick Answer: For a permanent backup on a drilled well, the Simple Pump deep well hand pump is the most capable option: Simple Pump rates it for static water levels up to 325 ft, it can pump into a pressure tank, and its own estimator put a 50 ft system at $1,980-$2,420 on November 6, 2026 (plus $170-$310 shipping). If you want a published, all-in price instead of a quote, the Flojak Plus cost $907.99 (50 ft) to $1,536.99 (200 ft) on flojak.com and fits beside a submersible in a 4 in. or larger casing. For water within 25 ft of the surface, a pitcher pump is enough. The number that decides which pump you need is the static water level, not the depth of the well.
A hand pump is the only way to get water out of a private well when the power is off and the generator is out of fuel. According to the U.S. Geological Survey, more than 43 million Americans, about 15% of the population, get their drinking water from private wells, and almost all of them depend on an electric submersible or jet pump to do it. When that pump stops, so does every tap, toilet and shower in the house.
We compared the hand pumps that US well owners actually choose between, using the makers’ own spec pages, warranty terms and support articles (Simple Pump, Bison Pumps, Flojak), prices from flojak.com, Simple Pump’s online price estimator and Lehman’s, which sells Simple Pump, Bison and Hitzer parts on one site, all checked on November 6, 2026. We don’t test products ourselves; every output, depth and price figure below comes from the source named next to it, and the strokes-per-gallon math is our own arithmetic on those published numbers.
Check current prices on eBay →
Static water level: the one measurement that picks the pump
A hand pump does not care how deep your well is. It cares how far below the ground the water sits when nothing is pumping, which is the static water level. A 400 ft well with water standing at 60 ft is a 60 ft job for a hand pump. Flojak’s FAQ puts it this way: lift starts at the static water level, so the effort is the same whether the pump inlet sits 20 ft or 100 ft below it.
There are two kinds of hand pump, and that number tells you which one you need:
- Suction (pitcher) pumps sit on top of the well and pull water up by vacuum. Physics caps them at about 25 ft of vertical lift; Bison rates its Model 1900 to 25 ft and Lehman’s lists the Green Hand cistern pump at 20 ft. Our shallow well pump guide explains the same 25 ft ceiling for electric jet pumps.
- Deep well lift pumps put a pumping cylinder under the water at the bottom of a string of drop pipe and push the water up with a rod. They are limited by how much weight you can lift with the handle, which is why makers rate them by static water level: 200 ft (Flojak Plus), 250 ft (Bison Standard) and 325 ft (Simple Pump).
Your well log from the driller usually lists the static water level, and some drillers write it under the well cap. If you can’t find it, Flojak’s FAQ describes the low-tech method: lower a weighted string until you hear the splash, mark it, and measure. Measure in late summer if you can, because Simple Pump tells buyers to size for the lowest seasonal level.
Well hand pumps compared at a glance
| Pump | Type | Max static water level (maker) | Output | Beside a submersible? | Price (Nov 6, 2026) | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Simple Pump Deep Well Hand Pump | Deep well lift, lever | 325 ft (4.5 oz cylinder) | 4.5-20 oz per stroke | Yes, extra parts may be needed | $1,980-$4,400 by depth + $170-$310 shipping | Lifetime, non-wear parts |
| Bison Standard Deep Well Pump System | Deep well lift, lever, all stainless head | 250 ft | 4-20 oz per stroke | Yes, in 5 in. OD or larger casing | Quote only; head $1,899.99 at Lehman's | Lifetime, non-wear parts |
| Flojak Plus | Deep well, T-handle, stainless + PVC | 200 ft lift | Up to 3 gpm at 50 ft | Yes, 4 in. and larger casings | $907.99 (50 ft) to $1,536.99 (200 ft) | Lifetime, non-wear parts |
| Flojak Ready | Deep well, T-handle | Kits 25-150 ft long | Not stated | Yes, mounts for 2-8 in. casings | $662.99 (25 ft) to $1,079.99 (150 ft) | Lifetime, non-wear parts |
| Flojak Rush | Deep well, no assembly | Kits 25 or 50 ft long | 1 gpm (Flojak) | Yes, drops in like a hose | $251.99 (25 ft), $333.99 (50 ft) | Lifetime |
| Bison Model 1900 | Pitcher (suction), stainless | 25 ft total vertical lift | 19 oz per stroke, 7 strokes/gal | Yes, tandem with electric pump | $1,860.00 at Lehman's | Lifetime, non-wear parts |
| Green Hand Cistern Pump | Pitcher (suction), cast iron | 20 ft | Not stated | Shallow wells and cisterns | $99.99 at Lehman's | Not stated by Lehman's |
1. Simple Pump Deep Well Hand Pump — Best Overall for a Permanent Backup
Simple Pump Deep Well Hand Pump System
- Three cylinder sizes, per Simple Pump's depth table: the 200CA (20 oz per stroke) to 110 ft, the 125CA (8.5 oz) to 225 ft and the 100CA (4.5 oz) to 325 ft of static water level.
- Simple Pump's estimator on November 6, 2026: $1,980-$2,420 at 50 ft, $2,250-$2,750 at 100 ft, $2,520-$3,080 at 150 ft, $2,790-$3,410 at 200 ft and $3,600-$4,400 at 325 ft. Shipping is $170-$310 extra.
- Pumps into a pressure tank with a connection kit, and can be motorized later (Simple Pump rates motor operation to 225 ft of total dynamic head).
- Lifetime parts-replacement warranty on non-wear parts; seals, guides, bushings and bearings are excluded. Simple Pump gives a typical seal interval of 5-10 years.
Simple Pump is the pump to beat when your water is deep or you want backup water at every tap, not just at the well head. It is the only pump here rated past 250 ft, and its cylinder table makes the trade-off visible: the 20 oz cylinder moves the most water but stops at 110 ft, while the 4.5 oz cylinder reaches 325 ft at less than a quarter of the output per stroke. Pick the largest cylinder your static water level allows.
The price is a range rather than a number because the drop pipe, rod and cylinder change with depth, and options such as a 36 in. lever, the Inline Dual-Pump Valve Assembly for sharing a pitless adapter, a pressure tank kit and a pitless adaptor kit are priced separately. One inconsistency to know about: the Simple Pump homepage said “Systems starting at $855” on November 6, while the same company’s estimator started at $940 for its shallow suction pump and $1,980 for the deep well system. The $855 figure is close to the price of the deep well pump head alone, which Lehman’s sold for $859 (standard height) or $959 (lower height), with the cylinder ($428-$638), drop pipe kits ($50-$65 each) and well cap ($120-$155) sold separately. Budget for the system, not the head.
2. Bison Standard Deep Well Pump System — Best All-Stainless Pump Head
Bison Pumps Standard Deep Well Pump System (side-by-side)
- Four stainless cylinders: 1.5 in. (4 oz per stroke), 2.0 in. (8 oz), 2.5 in. (12 oz) and 3.0 in. (20 oz), per Bison's spec table. Casing space decides which one fits.
- Ships with Schedule 120 PVC drop pipe and 3/8 in. stainless rod in 8 ft sections, enough to reach about 20 ft below your static water level; each section weighs about 8 lb.
- Bison's fit rules: no submersible and a casing of 4 in. OD or less, or a submersible plus a casing of 5 in. OD or more with a pitless adapter.
- Lifetime warranty on non-wearable parts; Bison only warrants the whole system's operation if the cylinder and pipe/rod also came from Bison.
Bison builds the most traditional-looking pump in this group: a 39 in., 25 lb welded stainless head with a 36 in. handle and a garden-hose spout. Bison does not publish system prices, saying on its product page that “a fixed cost for a pump system cannot be provided” because pipe and rod change with depth, so every order starts with a well information form. The only public price we found was Lehman’s listing of the Bison stainless deep well pump head at $1,899.99, more than double the Simple Pump head at the same store, before cylinder, pipe and rod.
Bison recommends two people for installation and mechanical lifting once a system goes past nine pipe sections (72 ft). With its Pressurizing System accessory ($159.50 for the check valve with gauge alone), it can also feed your pressure tank. Choose Bison if you want an all-stainless head and the 250 ft rating covers your well; choose Simple Pump if you need more depth or a published price range.
3. Flojak Plus — Best Value Deep Well Kit With a Published Price
Flojak Plus Hand Well Pump Kit
- Prices on flojak.com, November 6, 2026: 50 ft $907.99, 100 ft $1,112.99, 150 ft $1,324.99, 200 ft $1,536.99. A 50 ft extension kit costs $189.
- Flojak says to plan on 3 gpm from 50 ft down; a lever handle (PowerJak, $139, which Flojak calls a must-have past 70 ft) cuts the effort and also the flow.
- Designed to pressurize household plumbing through a hose to an outdoor faucet or the bladder tank.
- Assembles in 5 ft sections in 20-60 minutes, per Flojak; weighs about 40 lb per 50 ft.
Flojak is the cheapest way to put a permanent, pressure-capable deep well hand pump in a well, and the only maker here that sells complete kits at a fixed checkout price for every length. For a 50 ft static water level, the Flojak Plus you need (the 100 ft kit) cost $1,112.99 on November 6, against $1,980-$2,420 for a Simple Pump system at the same static level, before shipping. What you give up is depth and leverage: the standard handle is a T-handle, and the warranted lift is lower.
Check that warranted lift in writing. The Flojak Plus product page and FAQ answer 23 say it is rated and warranted for 200 ft of lift from static, but FAQ answer 12 and the extension-kit page say 150 ft. Flojak adds that it tests the design at 300 ft and that pumping deeper than the rating voids the warranty. If your static water level sits between 150 and 200 ft, ask Flojak which number applies before you order.
4. Flojak Ready — Best Emergency Kit to Keep in the Garage
Flojak Ready Hand Well Pump Kit
- Prices on flojak.com, November 6, 2026: 25 ft $662.99, 50 ft $734.99, 100 ft $856.99, 150 ft $1,079.99.
- Mounting options include a 2 in. well seal, which the Plus does not list; seals, well caps and the casing clamp cost $45.60-$99.00 extra on flojak.com.
- Flojak sells a "ReadyKit 100" ($974.99) with a field-shortening kit and casing clamp for people who don't know their well's specs yet.
- Lifetime warranty against defects, non-transferable; Flojak says to store it in a cool, dry place if it is not installed.
The Ready is built for the buyer who wants a hand pump on the shelf rather than in the well. You can install it permanently, but Flojak markets it as “peace of mind in a box” for an attic or garage, and the mounting options include 2 in. casings that the Plus does not list. Do one thing before you need it: check your casing clearance. Flojak’s own test is to slide a 10 to 20 ft length of 2 in. pipe down beside the existing plumbing. A pump that will not fit past the pitless adapter in a storm is not a backup.
The cheaper Flojak Rush ($251.99 for 25 ft, $333.99 for 50 ft, free shipping) needs no assembly at all: you uncoil it and lower it in. Flojak rates it at 1 gpm. Because Flojak tells buyers to reach at least 20 ft below the static water level, the 50 ft Rush only covers wells with water within about 30 ft of the surface.
5. Bison Model 1900 — Best for Shallow Wells and Cisterns
Bison Model 1900 Stainless Steel Pitcher Pump
- About 19 oz per stroke, or 7 strokes per gallon, per Bison, with no priming needed.
- Draws from wells, cisterns, ponds and rain-collection tanks, as long as total vertical lift stays at 25 ft or less.
- Can fill a pressure tank during an outage with Bison's Pressurizing System; a drain-back version exists for freezing climates.
- Pump head is 23 in. tall and 20 lb with a 2 in. NPT inlet and a 24 in. handle.
If your water stays within 25 ft of the pump, you don’t need a deep well system. The Bison Model 1900 is the premium choice: stainless instead of cast iron, a hose-thread spout and enough output that a gallon takes about seven strokes. Lehman’s, which listed it as Bison’s “Stainless Steel Shallow Well Pump” at $1,860.00 on November 6, sells it for cabins, cottages and hunting lodges because it mounts on almost any countertop, alone or in tandem with an electric pump. Simple Pump’s own shallow suction pump (PHA-2-S) is the alternative at $940-$1,045 in its estimator.
On a tight budget, the Green Hand Cistern Pump (American Granby) cost $99.99 at Lehman’s on November 6. It is a traditional cast-iron pitcher pump that Lehman’s rates to 20 ft of lift, fine for a shallow well, cistern or garden, but it is not stainless and Lehman’s lists no output or warranty. Like every pitcher pump, it must be drained before a hard freeze.
6. Hitzer Deep Well Lift Pump — Best Traditional Cast-Iron Yard Pump
Hitzer Deep Well Lift Pump (and Double-Acting Force Pump)
- Lehman's describes it as the pump the Amish use for farming and livestock, built for hard daily use and for forcing water to a house or barn.
- Price covers the head only; the cylinder, drop pipe and pump rod are sold separately and depend on your depth.
- The double-acting force pump pumps on both strokes and drains its force cylinder 4 ft down, below the frost line.
- Lehman's warns the force pump cannot be used with an electric pump because there isn't room in the casing for both.
The Hitzer is the choice for a farm, a livestock well or anyone who wants the classic pump-in-the-yard look and uses it every day. It is not the right pick for a backup on a modern home well: the force pump cannot share the casing with your submersible, and once you add a cylinder and pipe, the total climbs toward the price of a Flojak Plus without that kit’s published depth rating. Lehman’s lists it with 4 in. and 6 in. center well caps, a 6 in. offset cap and a platform mount.
How many strokes a gallon really takes
Output per stroke is the spec that matters most on a hand pump, and it falls as the cylinder gets smaller to reach deeper water. Using the makers’ own output figures, here is what a day of water costs in strokes. We used FEMA’s guideline of one gallon of water per person per day for drinking and sanitation, and 1.6 gallons for one toilet flush, the federal maximum for new toilets.
| Cylinder (maker rating) | Output per stroke | Strokes per gallon | Family of 4 for one day (4 gal) | One 1.6 gal toilet flush |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Simple Pump 200CA (to 110 ft) | 20 oz | 6.4 | 26 strokes | 10 strokes |
| Bison 3.0 in. cylinder | 20 oz | 6.4 | 26 strokes | 10 strokes |
| Bison Model 1900 pitcher (to 25 ft) | 19 oz | 6.7 (Bison: 7) | 27 strokes | 11 strokes |
| Bison 2.5 in. cylinder | 12 oz | 10.7 | 43 strokes | 17 strokes |
| Simple Pump 125CA (to 225 ft) | 8.5 oz | 15.1 | 60 strokes | 24 strokes |
| Simple Pump 100CA (to 325 ft) | 4.5 oz | 28.4 | 114 strokes | 46 strokes |
| Bison 1.5 in. cylinder | 4 oz | 32 | 128 strokes | 51 strokes |
The pattern is simple: drinking water is easy at any depth, and flushing is what wears you out. With the deepest Simple Pump cylinder, a single flush takes about 46 strokes. That is the honest case for pumping into the pressure tank, or for keeping a bucket by the toilet and flushing only when needed.
What a full system costs at your depth
Because Flojak tells buyers to reach at least 20 ft below the static water level, its kit length is not the same as your water depth. This table lines up each maker’s price at the same static water level, using Flojak’s 20 ft rule to pick the kit length (prices November 6, 2026):
| Static water level | Simple Pump (estimator, before shipping) | Flojak Ready (kit length) | Flojak Plus (kit length) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Up to 25 ft | $940-$1,045 (shallow suction pump) | $734.99 (50 ft) | $907.99 (50 ft) |
| 50 ft | $1,980-$2,420 | $856.99 (100 ft) | $1,112.99 (100 ft) |
| 100 ft | $2,250-$2,750 | $1,079.99 (150 ft) | $1,324.99 (150 ft) |
| 150 ft | $2,520-$3,080 | Not offered | $1,536.99 (200 ft) |
| 200 ft | $2,790-$3,410 | Not offered | $1,725.99 (200 ft + 50 ft extension), at the edge of the rating |
| 250-325 ft | $3,150-$4,400 | Not offered | Not rated |
At 50 ft, the Flojak Ready costs less than half of Simple Pump’s low estimate. The gap pays for a lever arm instead of a T-handle, a deeper rating and a dealer network. Bison is missing from this table because it only quotes by well.
Pumping into your pressure tank: the hidden depth cost
All three deep well makers sell a way to push water into your household pressure tank, so the faucets and toilets work during an outage. The catch is that pressure counts as extra lift. Simple Pump’s support article uses the standard conversion of 1 psi = 2.31 ft of water: a tank at 40 psi adds 92 ft and a tank at 50 psi adds 116 ft. Its own example takes the 325 ft hand-pump limit down to 209 ft for a 50 psi system. Flojak’s FAQ puts the cost of charging household pressure at “about 50 feet of lift,” which only holds for a tank run at roughly 22 psi.
So if your static water level is 120 ft and you want to fill a 30/50 tank, size the pump as if the water were at about 236 ft (120 ft plus 116 ft). That rules out the Flojak Plus (200 ft) and Simple Pump’s 20 oz and 8.5 oz cylinders (110 ft and 225 ft), leaving Simple Pump’s 4.5 oz cylinder (325 ft) or a Bison system close to its 250 ft rating. If you only want buckets at the well head, size for the static water level alone. Our well water pressure tank guide explains cut-in and cut-out settings if you are not sure what your tank runs at.
Before you buy: casing room, freezing and water quality
Casing room. Most home wells already have a submersible pump, its drop pipe, a safety rope and an electrical cable inside the casing, plus a pitless adapter a few feet down. A backup hand pump has to slide past all of it. Flojak needs about 2 in. of clearance, Bison’s side-by-side system wants a casing of at least 5 in. outside diameter when a submersible is present, and Simple Pump prices installs beside a submersible by custom quote. Every kit also changes the top of the well: the pump mounts through the cap or replaces it, and whatever goes back on has to seal. Our well cap guide explains how to size a sanitary cap by casing outside diameter. If the casing is damaged or you are unsure, read our well casing repair guide before you drop anything in.
Freezing. Deep well hand pumps drain below the frost line after each use: Simple Pump lists its pump as freeze-proof, Bison calls its Standard system freeze proof, and Flojak drains through a weep hole about 50 in. below the top. Pitcher pumps hold water above ground and need draining or a drain-back design.
Water quality. A hand pump changes how water leaves the well, not what is in it. Water you pump at the well head bypasses every treatment system in the house, and even water you pump into the pressure tank skips any device that needs electricity, such as a UV water filter. During an outage, treat hand-pumped drinking water with a non-electric gravity water filter or boil it, and if the well flooded, follow our boil water advisory guide until a test says otherwise. Flojak also recommends disinfecting the well with household bleach the day you install, and any work inside the casing is a good reason to retest using our well water testing guide.
Recalls. We found no recall of a hand-operated well pump in the Consumer Product Safety Commission’s recall database on November 6, 2026. The two well pump recalls it lists, Monarch in 1995 and Davey’s DynaDrive in 2023, both concern electric pumps.
The bottom line
Find your static water level first, then buy for it. For water within 25 ft, a pitcher pump does the job, from the $99.99 Green Hand cast-iron pump to the stainless Bison Model 1900. For a deep well on a budget, the Flojak Plus ($907.99-$1,536.99) is the best value and the easiest to price, and the Flojak Ready is the kit to keep on the shelf. For a permanent backup that can feed the whole house from deep water, the Simple Pump is the most capable choice, with a 325 ft rating and a lever arm that makes deep pumping practical, at roughly twice the price at the same depth. If your static water level is deeper than 250 ft, or deeper than about 135 ft and you want to fill a 50 psi tank, Simple Pump is the only pump here rated for it; its own example puts the 50 psi limit at 209 ft. For your everyday electric pump, see our best submersible well pump picks.
Prices were checked on flojak.com, Simple Pump’s online estimator and lehmans.com on November 6, 2026, and change often; specs and ratings come from the makers’ product pages, support articles and warranty terms. We don’t test products ourselves.